PUMPKIN BARS ARE BACK!
We are currently closed to online sales.
Our Products
We are known best for our Cheeseballs, which are all made from scratch by hand. Our choice of cheese combinations give our Cheeseballs the smooth texture that people have come to love. We have two flavors; pimento & onion and jalapeño, and now a dessert S'mores cheeseball that can only be found at our store in Milford. Our Cheeseballs are well known throughout the Midwest and some have even made their way across the country and overseas. You can find Theresa's Homemade Cheeseballs in 30 different stores across Indiana, including all Rise'N Roll stores and Rentown Country Store.
We are also a made-from-scratch bakery/cafe. We serve breakfast, lunch, and of course, many sweet treats. Among our variety of treats, our cinnamon rolls are a customer favorite and our kolaches are special pastries that can't be found many other places in this area of the country. We also make cakes, pies, party trays, and many more custom orders. Give us a call and we'll talk treats!
Our Story
After selling at annual craft shows for over 15 years, it became apparent that our customers wanted our Cheeseballs year-round. So on July 5th, 2014, we opened up our little store-front bakery as a new home to make our Cheeseballs. We started with less than 300 sq ft., and after taking over the unit next-door, we realized we still needed room to grow. One block away and a few years later, our Cheeseballs are still made by hand by us: Theresa and Randy.
We take pride in being a mom-and-pop made from humble beginnings. If it wasn't for our loyal customers loving our Cheeseballs so much, we wouldn't be here today. We thank our customers for helping our Cheeseballs take off and expand and for helping our bakery/cafe venture reach new heights.
Our Mission
Theresa and Randy's mission is to treat you as family, as a best friend, and have you try the best Cheeseballs around! Our customers will be able to tell that we are one-of-a-kind. We take pride in caring about the products we serve and the people we serve them to.
We carefully crafted our recipes to give each customer a taste of home. From our cookies to our biscuits and gravy to our cheeseballs; our goal is to have every bite as comforting as the last. That's why we go the extra mile -- to ensure we live up to the title of a made-from-scratch bakery.
We strive to make our repeat customers will feel as welcome as family members, and our first-time customers leave feeling satisfied with the warm service and good food. And our final goal is to have everyone try a cheeseball. No one can eat it just once!
Some of our sweet treats
Donuts -- Made fresh daily
For several dozen or more, call us the day before. We have a variety of fresh doughnuts each day, and we have day-old doughnuts at a reduced price.
Delicious pastries
Huge homemade cinnamon rolls, sweet danish, and fluffy turnovers.
Made-from-scratch cookies
Each cookie is made and scooped into generous portions by hand. We have eight varieties of these big cookies, as well as iced sugar cookies topped with homemade buttercream.